Resources / 5: Assessment / Other Measures of Personality

Maya times the bunny on a red and white block puzzle

Other Measures of Personality

5: Assessment

Study guide by Anders Chan, PsyD · Updated

Understanding Personality Assessment Tools: Your Guide to Structured and Projective Tests

You're sitting across from a new client who's struggling at work. They can't figure out why they clash with certain colleagues or why they feel constantly anxious. Or maybe you're assessing someone for career counseling, and they need clarity about their strengths and preferences. How do you get a clear picture of who they really are? This is where personality measures come in, and knowing which tool to use (and why) is crucial for your practice and definitely for the EPPP.

Personality tests fall into two main camps: structured tests (where questions have clear, specific answers) and projective tests (where people respond to ambiguous images and reveal themselves indirectly). Let's break down the most important ones you'll need to know.

Structured Personality Tests: The Multiple-Choice Approach

Structured personality tests work by asking direct questions with fixed response options. Think of them like a detailed questionnaire you might fill out for a dating app, the questions are straightforward, the answers are clear, and you're consciously choosing how to present yourself. These tests are objective, meaning different examiners will score them the same way.

Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire (16 PF)

Raymond Cattell created the 16 PF in 1949 using a fascinating approach. He started with the lexical strategy, which assumes that if a personality trait is important, people will have created words for it. It's like how we now have specific words for texting behaviors ("ghosting," "breadcrumbing," "left on read") because these patterns matter in our social lives. Cattell combed through the English language, found all the personality-describing words, then used factor analysis (a statistical method that groups related items together) to condense thousands of descriptors into manageable categories.

The result? Sixteen primary traits and five broader global traits:

Global TraitWhat It MeasuresPrimary Traits Included
ExtraversionSociability and energyWarmth, liveliness, social boldness
AnxietyEmotional stabilityVigilance, apprehension, tension
Tough-mindednessThinking styleAbstractedness, sensitivity, openness to change
IndependenceAutonomy and dominanceDominance, social boldness, vigilance
Self-controlRestraint and perfectionismRule-consciousness, perfectionism

The 16 PF gives you a detailed profile. It's like having both a broad map of someone's personality landscape and a zoomed-in view of specific neighborhoods. You get the big picture and the details.

Edwards Personal Preference Schedule (EPPS)

The EPPS, developed by Edwards in 1959, takes a different approach. It's based on Henry Murray's system of human needs, the same framework behind the TAT (which we'll discuss later). The test measures 15 basic psychological needs like achievement, affiliation (wanting to belong), dominance, and autonomy.

Here's what makes it unique: The EPPS uses a forced-choice format. Each question presents two statements, both relatively neutral in social desirability, and you must pick one. Imagine being asked whether you'd rather spend Friday evening networking at a professional event or working alone on a passion project. Both are socially acceptable, but your choice reveals something about your needs.

This format produces ipsative scores, which is fancy terminology for "relative rankings." Here's the critical point for the EPPP: Ipsative scores tell you which needs are strongest within a person (intra-individual comparison) but can't compare how strong someone's needs are relative to other people (inter-individual comparison). It's like knowing you prefer coffee to tea without knowing if you're actually a heavy caffeine consumer compared to the general population. You can't use these scores to say "Person A needs achievement more than Person B does," only that "Person A values achievement more than they value affiliation."

Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)

You've probably encountered this one. It's everywhere from corporate team-building to online personality quizzes. Myers and Briggs developed it between 1943 and 1962 based on Carl Jung's personality typology.

The MBTI measures four bipolar dimensions (meaning each dimension has two opposite ends):

DimensionWhat It Measures
Introversion (I) vs. Extraversion (E)Where you get energy: from internal reflection or external interaction
Sensing (S) vs. Intuition (N)How you gather information: concrete facts or abstract patterns
Thinking (T) vs. Feeling (F)How you make decisions: logical analysis or personal values
Judging (J) vs. Perceiving (P)How you approach the outside world: structured planning or flexible adapting

Your results place you into one of 16 personality types. Combinations like ISTP or ENFJ. Each type is like a personality recipe with four ingredients, and the combination creates a distinct pattern of behavior and preferences.

Here's something important: While the MBTI is popular and can be useful for self-reflection and career exploration, it has received criticism in academic psychology for reliability and validity issues. You should know it for the EPPP because it's widely used, but be aware of its limitations in clinical settings.

NEO Personality Inventory-3 (NEO-PI-3)

This is the gold standard for measuring the Big Five personality traits. The five factors themselves came out of the lexical tradition: like Cattell, researchers factor-analyzed the words people use to describe each other, but they landed on five core traits instead of sixteen. Goldberg gave them the name "Big Five" (Goldberg, 1990). Costa and McCrae built the questionnaire: their NEO Personality Inventory (1985) became the standard measure of this Five-Factor Model (McCrae & John, 1992).

The Big Five can be remembered with the acronyms OCEAN or CANOE:

TraitWhat It MeansExample Facets
Openness to ExperienceCuriosity, imagination, appreciation for art and new ideasFantasy, aesthetics, feelings, ideas
ConscientiousnessOrganization, responsibility, self-disciplineCompetence, order, achievement striving, self-discipline
ExtraversionSociability, assertiveness, energyWarmth, gregariousness, assertiveness, excitement-seeking
AgreeablenessCompassion, cooperation, trustTrust, straightforwardness, altruism, compliance
NeuroticismEmotional instability, tendency toward negative emotionsAnxiety, hostility, depression, self-consciousness

The NEO-PI-3 doesn't just give you scores on these five traits. It also measures six specific facets under each trait, 30 facets in all, across 240 items for ages 12 and up (PAR, n.d.). If the Big Five traits are chapters in someone's personality book, the facets are the individual paragraphs that tell the detailed story.

Here's a clinically significant finding you should know: Research has consistently linked Big Five patterns to psychological disorders. A meta-analysis of anxiety, depressive, and substance use disorders found every diagnostic group high on neuroticism (average d = 1.65) and low on conscientiousness (average d = -1.01). Substance use disorders stood out for high disinhibition and low agreeableness (Kotov et al., 2010).

A major meta-analysis by Aschwanden and colleagues in 2021 found that high neuroticism and low conscientiousness are associated with increased risk for Alzheimer's disease and related dementias (neuroticism hazard ratio 1.24; conscientiousness hazard ratio 0.77). That is a population-level risk association, not a screening use. The NEO is not a dementia test.

PID-5: The Maladaptive Big Five

The Personality Inventory for DSM-5 (PID-5) measures the trait model in the DSM-5-TR Alternative Model for Personality Disorders (Section III). Its five domains are maladaptive variants of the Big Five (American Psychiatric Association, 2022, Section III):

PID-5 domainOpposite (healthy) poleBig Five link
Negative AffectivityEmotional StabilityHigh Neuroticism
DetachmentExtraversionLow Extraversion
AntagonismAgreeablenessLow Agreeableness
DisinhibitionConscientiousnessLow Conscientiousness
PsychoticismLucidity(Unusual, eccentric thinking)

The full form has 220 items rated 0-3 and covers 25 facets (Krueger et al., 2012). There is a self-report form and an informant form, and APA lets clinicians reproduce it for use with their patients. Exam hook: the NEO describes normal personality; the PID-5 describes personality pathology along the same five dimensions.

Projective Personality Tests: Reading Between the Lines

Now we shift to a completely different approach. Projective tests operate on the assumption that when you give people ambiguous, unstructured stimuli and freedom to respond however they want, they'll unconsciously reveal their inner world: their conflicts, needs, and personality structure. It's like looking at clouds and seeing shapes. What you see isn't really in the cloud; it comes from your own mind.

Rorschach Inkblot Test

Hermann Rorschach published this test in 1921, and it remains one of the most recognizable psychological instruments. The test includes 10 cards with bilaterally symmetrical inkblots (five in black and gray, two with red, and three multicolored).

How it works:

Administration typically has two phases. In the free association phase, the examiner shows cards one at a time and asks, "What might this be?" The client responds however they want. They might see one thing or many things, talk briefly or extensively. Then comes the inquiry phase, where the examiner asks follow-up questions to understand what parts of the inkblot and what characteristics (shape, color, perceived movement) led to each response.

Exner's Comprehensive System is a widely-used scoring method. It categorizes responses along several dimensions:

Location: Which part of the inkblot did the person focus on?

  • Whole responses (using the entire inkblot)
  • Common detail responses (typical sections)
  • Unusual detail responses (rare or small sections)

Determinants: What characteristics influenced the response?

  • Form (the shape)
  • Movement (perceived action)
  • Color
  • Shading

Content: What category does the response fall into?

  • Human figures
  • Animals
  • Nature elements
  • Objects

Form Quality: How well does the response match the actual inkblot shape? (Good form quality suggests reality testing is intact)

Popularity: Is this a common response? (Many popular responses suggest conventional thinking)

Here's where interpretation gets interesting. Different response patterns indicate different psychological characteristics:

  • Many color responses suggest strong emotionality and impulsiveness, the person responds quickly to emotional stimuli
  • Many whole responses indicate creative, theoretical thinking, the ability to see the big picture
  • Confabulation (taking one detail and overgeneralizing it to the whole inkblot) can suggest cognitive impairment, brain injury, or thought disorders like schizophrenia

Imagine someone who looks at every inkblot and immediately reacts to the colors with emotional responses versus someone who carefully analyzes the entire structure before responding. These different approaches reveal different cognitive and emotional styles.

R-PAS: The Newer Rorschach System

The Rorschach Performance Assessment System (R-PAS) was published in 2011 by Meyer, Viglione, Mihura, Erard, and Erdberg as a successor to Exner's Comprehensive System (CS). Know three changes:

  • R-Optimized administration. The examiner asks for two, or maybe three, responses to each card, prompts for another if the person gives only one, and takes no more than four per card (Viglione et al., 2015). This keeps the number of responses (R) in a usable range. In one comparison of nonpatients, 78% of R-PAS protocols landed in the optimal range of 18-27 responses, versus 24% under the CS (Pianowski et al., 2021).
  • International norms instead of a single U.S. reference sample (Pianowski et al., 2016).
  • Evidence-based variables. A large set of meta-analyses of the 65 main CS variables found validity of r = .27, on average, against outside criteria such as observer ratings and diagnosis, but only r = .08 against self-report. Support was strongest for variables tapping perception and thinking (such as the Perceptual-Thinking Index) and weakest for some scales such as the Egocentricity Index (Mihura et al., 2013). Two R-PAS authors, Meyer and Mihura, also led that review.

R-PAS is like a remaster of a classic album: same ten cards, but the producers dropped the tracks that never worked and tightened the levels.

Thematic Apperception Test (TAT)

Henry Murray developed the TAT in 1943, building on his theory of human needs (the same framework that informed the EPPS). The full set has 31 cards. Thirty show a picture with one or more people in different situations, and one card is blank. The pictures are deliberately ambiguous. You might see people talking, but you don't know what they're saying or feeling.

How it works:

The client looks at each picture and creates a complete story that includes:

  • What's happening in the scene
  • What events led up to this moment
  • What the characters are thinking and feeling
  • How the story ends

Murray's scoring system focuses on:

The hero: Which character does the client identify with? This is typically the character the client talks about most or describes in greatest detail.

Needs: What does the hero want or need? (Achievement, affiliation, power, autonomy, etc.)

Press: What forces are acting on the hero? These can be internal (feelings, thoughts) or external (other people, circumstances)

Outcomes: How does the story end? Positive, negative, ambiguous?

Think about how when friends describe a conflict at work, they naturally position themselves as the protagonist and reveal what matters most to them through the details they emphasize, the TAT works the same way, but with standardized images.

The patterns across multiple stories reveal recurring themes. If someone consistently tells stories about achievement despite obstacles, about betrayal in relationships, or about powerlessness, these themes likely reflect their inner world and concerns.

Comparing Structured and Projective Approaches

FeatureStructured TestsProjective Tests
Question formatClear, direct questionsAmbiguous stimuli
ScoringObjective, standardizedMore subjective, requires training
What they measureConscious self-descriptionUnconscious processes and dynamics
ReliabilityGenerally higherGenerally lower
Time to administerUsually shorterUsually longer
Best used forTrait description, screeningClinical assessment, deeper exploration

Common Misconceptions for the EPPP

Misconception 1: "Projective tests are unreliable and invalid, so they're not used anymore."

Reality: While projective tests have lower reliability than structured tests, they remain widely used, especially in clinical and forensic settings. The Rorschach, when scored with systems like Exner's, has demonstrated acceptable reliability and validity for certain purposes. Validity varies by variable: support is strongest for perception and thinking variables and weak for others (Mihura et al., 2013). Know both the limitations and the continued applications.

Misconception 2: "The MBTI is scientifically rigorous because it's so popular."

Reality: Popularity doesn't equal scientific validity. The MBTI is popular in organizational settings but has significant limitations. For the EPPP, know what it measures and how it works, but also understand it's not typically the first choice for clinical assessment.

Misconception 3: "Ipsative scores from the EPPS can be compared between people."

Reality: This is a critical distinction. Ipsative scores only allow intra-individual comparisons (within one person). You cannot use EPPS results to say one person has higher achievement needs than another person. Only that achievement ranks higher or lower within each person's own need profile.

Misconception 4: "High neuroticism on the NEO means someone has a mental disorder."

Reality: The Big Five traits are dimensional. Everyone falls somewhere on each continuum. High neuroticism indicates a tendency toward negative emotions and stress reactivity, which is a risk factor for various disorders, but it's not a diagnosis itself.

Practice Tips for Remembering

For the Big Five (OCEAN): Create a vivid mental scene. Picture yourself standing by the OCEAN. You're Conscientious about not littering, Extraverted enough to chat with people nearby, Agreeable when someone asks to borrow your sunscreen, and experiencing Neuroticism about whether you applied enough. Meanwhile, your Openness to experience leads you to try that unusual food truck you've never seen before.

For distinguishing tests: Make a simple chart that lists each test's key feature:

TestKey Feature to Remember
16 PF16 primary traits from WORDS (lexical)
EPPS15 NEEDS, forced-choice, IPSATIVE scores (no comparing people)
MBTI4 dimensions, 16 TYPES, based on Jung
NEO-PI-3Big Five (OCEAN), 6 FACETS per trait; neuroticism high across anxiety, depression, and SUD
RorschachINKBLOTS, Exner's system, color = emotion, confabulation = problems
TATSTORIES about pictures, identify hero's needs and press

For the Rorschach scoring categories: Use the acronym L-D-C-F-P:

  • Location
  • Determinants
  • Content
  • Form quality
  • Popularity

For remembering which test is which: Focus on what makes each unique:

  • Cattell's 16 PF = Started with language/words
  • EPPS = Only one with forced-choice and ipsative scores
  • MBTI = Only one with 16 types (combinations)
  • NEO = The "Big Five" standard
  • Rorschach = Only inkblots
  • TAT = Only storytelling

Real-World Applications

In clinical practice: You might use the NEO-PI-3 during an initial assessment to understand a client's personality structure, particularly if you're doing longer-term therapy. The trait profile can help predict which therapeutic approaches might work best and what challenges might arise. Someone high in neuroticism and low in agreeableness might be more skeptical of your interventions and more prone to emotional reactivity in sessions.

In forensic psychology: Do not assume the Rorschach is hard to fake. A preregistered meta-analysis of 21 studies found that people feigning severe mental illness raised Rorschach indicators of perception and thinking problems and exaggerated indicators of stress and distress (Pimentel & Meyer, 2026). Structured inventories like the MMPI have dedicated overreporting scales; the Rorschach has no established overreporting index, and researchers are still testing candidate composites (Pimentel & Meyer, 2026). When feigning is a concern, rely on validated validity scales and stand-alone validity tests (see the MMPI lesson).

In career counseling: The MBTI, despite its limitations, can facilitate conversations about work preferences and communication styles. Just be careful about using it for selection decisions or treating types as fixed categories rather than preferences.

In neuropsychological assessment: Personality inventories are not tools for detecting cognitive decline. The link between high neuroticism, low conscientiousness, and later dementia is a population-level risk association (Aschwanden et al., 2021). Cognitive screening and neuropsychological tests answer the cognitive question.

In research: The Big Five traits measured by the NEO have become standard in personality research, allowing studies to be compared across different populations and cultures. When you read research about personality and health, career success, or relationship satisfaction, it's usually using the Big Five framework.

Key Takeaways

  • Structured personality tests use direct questions with fixed answers; they're objective and measure conscious self-description

  • The 16 PF identified 16 primary traits and 5 global factors using the lexical strategy (important traits are encoded in language)

  • The EPPS measures 15 needs using forced-choice format; produces ipsative scores that allow intra-individual but NOT inter-individual comparisons

  • The MBTI measures 4 bipolar dimensions based on Jung's theory, creating 16 personality types; widely used but has reliability/validity concerns

  • The NEO-PI-3 is the gold standard for measuring the Big Five (OCEAN/CANOE); 6 facets under each trait (30 total). The Big Five came from lexical research (Goldberg named them); Costa and McCrae built the NEO. Anxiety, depressive, and substance use disorders all run high on neuroticism and low on conscientiousness (Kotov et al., 2010). High neuroticism + low conscientiousness are also associated with higher dementia risk, but the NEO is not a dementia screen

  • The PID-5 measures the five maladaptive trait domains of the DSM-5-TR Alternative Model for Personality Disorders: Negative Affectivity, Detachment, Antagonism, Disinhibition, Psychoticism

  • R-PAS (2011) is the newer Rorschach system: R-Optimized administration (two or three responses per card, no more than four) and international norms. Rorschach validity is strongest for perception and thinking variables (Mihura et al., 2013)

  • The Rorschach is not "fake-proof": people feigning severe illness can raise its perception and thinking indicators (Pimentel & Meyer, 2026)

  • Projective tests assume people reveal unconscious processes when responding to ambiguous stimuli

  • The Rorschach uses 10 inkblots; Exner's Comprehensive System scores responses by Location, Determinants, Content, Form quality, and Popularity

  • Rorschach interpretation: Color responses = emotionality/impulsiveness; whole responses = creative thinking; confabulation = possible cognitive impairment or psychosis

  • The TAT presents ambiguous pictures; examinees tell stories revealing needs, press, and themes through the hero character

  • Know the differences: structured tests are more reliable but measure only conscious processes; projective tests access deeper material but require more training to interpret

With this foundation, you're prepared to tackle EPPP questions about personality assessment. Focus on what makes each test unique, what it measures, and its key limitations. Good luck with your studies!

Trait dimensions and personality assessment

The Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire measures primary personality traits as dimensions. Its scores describe a trait profile rather than assigning a person to a single personality type. Distinguish this dimensional approach from type classifications and from clinical symptom assessment (Wasmund & Tate, 1988).

Traits describe tendencies

Traits describe relatively stable tendencies in how a person feels, thinks, and acts. Relative stability over time does not mean identical behavior in every situation. A trait score is one part of understanding a person, not a guarantee about every future action (Strauss & Smith, 2009).

Sources added 2026-10-08

  • Lewis R Goldberg. An alternative "description of personality": the big-five factor structure. Journal of personality and social psychology. 1990 Dec;59(6):1216-29. doi:10.1037//0022-3514.59.6.1216. PMID:2283588. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2283588/
  • Robert R McCrae, Oliver P John. An introduction to the five-factor model and its applications. Journal of personality. 1992 Jun;60(2):175-215. doi:10.1111/j.1467-6494.1992.tb00970.x. PMID:1635039. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1635039/
  • Roman Kotov, Wakiza Gamez, Frank Schmidt, David Watson. Linking "big" personality traits to anxiety, depressive, and substance use disorders: a meta-analysis. Psychological bulletin. 2010 Sep;136(5):768-821. doi:10.1037/a0020327. PMID:20804236. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20804236/
  • Damaris Aschwanden, Jason E Strickhouser, Martina Luchetti, et al. Is personality associated with dementia risk? A meta-analytic investigation. Ageing research reviews. 2021 May;67:101269. doi:10.1016/j.arr.2021.101269. PMID:33561581. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33561581/
  • Raquel P F A Pimentel, Gregory J Meyer. Feigning and Malingering Severe Psychopathology on the Rorschach Test: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Assessment. 2026 Jul 28. doi:10.1177/10731911261462465. PMID:42522014. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42522014/
  • Joni L Mihura, Gregory J Meyer, Nicolae Dumitrascu, George Bombel. The validity of individual Rorschach variables: systematic reviews and meta-analyses of the comprehensive system. Psychological bulletin. 2013 May;139(3):548-605. doi:10.1037/a0029406. PMID:22925137. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22925137/
  • Giselle Pianowski, Gregory J Meyer, Anna Elisa de Villemor-Amaral, et al. Does the Rorschach Performance Assessment System (R-PAS) Differ from the Comprehensive System (CS) on Variables Relevant to Interpretation? Journal of personality assessment. 2021;103(1):132-147. doi:10.1080/00223891.2019.1677678. PMID:31633395. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31633395/
  • Giselle Pianowski, Gregory J Meyer, Anna Elisa Villemor-Amaral. The Impact of R-Optimized Administration Modeling Procedures on Brazilian Normative Reference Values for Rorschach Scores. Journal of personality assessment. 2016;98(4):408-18. doi:10.1080/00223891.2016.1148701. PMID:27003633. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27003633/
  • Donald J Viglione, Gregory Meyer, Rebecca J Jordan, et al. Developing an Alternative Rorschach Administration Method to Optimize the Number of Responses and Enhance Clinical Inferences. Clinical psychology & psychotherapy. 2015 Nov-Dec;22(6):546-58. doi:10.1002/cpp.1913. PMID:25103094. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25103094/
  • Robert F Krueger, Jaime Derringer, Kristian E Markon, David Watson, Andrew E Skodol. Initial construction of a maladaptive personality trait model and inventory for DSM-5. Psychological medicine. 2012 Sep;42(9):1879-90. doi:10.1017/S0033291711002674. PMID:22153017. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22153017/
  • American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed., text rev.), Section III, Alternative DSM-5 Model for Personality Disorders (personality trait model).
  • PAR. (n.d.). NEO Personality Inventory-3 (NEO-PI-3). https://www.parinc.com/products/NEO-PI-3

Ready to practice?

Get started in the app