Understanding Trauma, Dissociation, and Somatic Symptoms: A Practical Guide
When someone walks into your office complaining of paralysis that no medical test can explain, or a combat veteran who can't stop reliving the moment his convoy was attacked, or a parent who reports memory gaps around a childhood trauma. You're dealing with some of psychology's most challenging presentations. These disorders sit at the intersection of mind and body, often blurring the lines between physical symptoms and psychological pain.
This lesson will walk you through three major categories that frequently appear on the EPPP: Trauma/Stressor-Related Disorders, Dissociative Disorders, and Somatic Symptom Disorders. Understanding these conditions isn't just about memorizing criteria. It's about recognizing how the human mind protects itself, sometimes in ways that create more problems than they solve.
Why These Disorders Matter for Your Practice
These three categories sit side by side in DSM-5-TR, but they are not defined the same way. Only the trauma- and stressor-related disorders require a stressful or traumatic event. Dissociative disorders often follow trauma, and somatic symptom disorders can arise with no stressor at all. Whether someone is re-experiencing trauma, disconnecting from reality, or struggling with distressing physical symptoms, these presentations require careful assessment and evidence-based treatment. For the EPPP, you'll need to distinguish between similar-sounding disorders and understand which treatments actually work based on research evidence.
Trauma and Stressor-Related Disorders: When Bad Events Leave Lasting Marks
All disorders in this category require exposure to a traumatic or stressful event as part of the diagnosis. This is crucial for the EPPP. You can't diagnose any of these conditions without establishing that a triggering event occurred.
Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD)
This diagnosis applies when a child's early caregiving was so inadequate that it fundamentally disrupted their ability to form healthy emotional connections. You're looking for two core features:
- The child consistently pulls away from adult caregivers emotionally. They don't seek comfort when upset and don't respond when comfort is offered
- Persistent social and emotional problems that include at least two symptoms: minimal emotional responsiveness, limited positive emotions, or unexplained fear/sadness/irritability around adult caregivers
Critical diagnostic requirements:
- History of extreme insufficient care (neglect, frequent caregiver changes, institutional settings with poor care)
- Symptoms started before age 5
- Child has a developmental age of at least 9 months (so you know they're developmentally capable of attachment)
- Criteria are not met for autism spectrum disorder (a key RAD vs. ASD rule-out, since both can look socially withdrawn)
Think of attachment like learning your first language. There's a critical window when the brain is primed to develop these connections. When that window closes without proper input, catching up becomes much harder.
Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder (DSED)
This disorder also stems from inadequate early care, but manifests differently. Instead of withdrawing, these children show inappropriately friendly behavior with strangers. They need at least two of these four symptoms:
- Little to no hesitation approaching or interacting with unfamiliar adults
- Overly familiar behavior (verbal or physical) with strangers
- Doesn't check back with caregivers after separation
- Willingly goes off with strangers with minimal hesitation
The key distinction for the EPPP: RAD involves emotional withdrawal; DSED involves indiscriminate sociability. Both require a history of insufficient care and a developmental age of at least 9 months.
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
This is the heavyweight of trauma disorders and deserves your focused attention for the exam. PTSD requires exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violence. The exposure can be direct, witnessed, learned about (when it happened to a close family member or friend), or through repeated exposure to details (like first responders experience).
Two exposure details the exam likes:
- Learning about a traumatic event counts only if it happened to a close family member or friend, and a death must have been violent or accidental
- Exposure through TV, movies, pictures, or electronic media does not count unless it is part of the person's work
Symptoms must last more than one month and fall into four categories:
| Symptom Category | Examples | Minimum needed |
|---|---|---|
| Intrusion | Distressing memories, nightmares, flashbacks, psychological/physical reactions to reminders | 1 of 5 |
| Avoidance | Avoiding memories, thoughts, feelings about the trauma; avoiding external reminders (people, places, activities) | 1 of 2 |
| Negative Mood/Cognition | Inability to remember key aspects, persistent negative beliefs, distorted blame, negative emotional state, diminished interest, detachment, inability to feel positive emotions | 2 of 7 |
| Altered Arousal/Reactivity | Irritability, reckless behavior, hypervigilance, exaggerated startle, concentration problems, sleep disturbance | 2 of 6 |
Specifiers:
- With dissociative symptoms: persistent depersonalization or derealization in addition to PTSD
- With delayed expression: full criteria are not met until at least 6 months after the event (some symptoms may start right away)
Young children: DSM-5-TR has a separate set of PTSD criteria for children 6 and younger, with fewer symptoms required (for example, 1 avoidance or negative-mood symptom).
Prevalence: lifetime DSM-5 PTSD is about 6.1%-8.3% in U.S. adults, and 12-month prevalence is 4.7%. Women are affected about twice as often (lifetime 8%-11% vs. 4.1%-5.4% for men), partly because of greater exposure to sexual assault and other interpersonal violence.
Brain Changes in PTSD
The neuroscience here is testable, so pay attention:
- Hyperactive amygdala: The brain's alarm system is stuck in overdrive
- Hyperactive anterior cingulate cortex: Increased emotional processing
- Hypoactive ventromedial prefrontal cortex: The "brake pedal" that normally calms the amygdala isn't working properly. This creates a runaway fear response
- Reduced hippocampal volume: The memory center is actually smaller
- Neurotransmitter changes: Increased dopamine, norepinephrine, and glutamate; decreased serotonin and GABA
Picture a car alarm system that's become so sensitive it goes off at the slightest vibration, while the off-switch has stopped working properly. That's essentially what's happening with the amygdala-prefrontal cortex relationship in PTSD.
Risk Factors for Developing PTSD
Not everyone who experiences trauma develops PTSD. Pre-trauma factors that increase risk include:
- Prior trauma exposure
- Prior psychiatric disorders
- Negative affectivity (tendency toward negative emotions)
- Female gender
- Low education and socioeconomic status
- Lack of social support
- Exposure to racial/ethnic discrimination
Evidence-Based PTSD Treatment
The APA Clinical Practice Guideline (2025) provides clear hierarchy you need to know:
First-line psychological treatments (recommended):
- Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT)
- Prolonged Exposure (PE)
- Trauma-focused CBT
Second-line psychological treatments (suggested):
- Cognitive Therapy (CT)
- Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR)
- Narrative Exposure Therapy (NET)
Medication: No first-line medication recommendations exist. Second-line options include:
- SSRIs: fluoxetine, paroxetine, sertraline
- SNRI: venlafaxine
These medications help with comorbid depression and may reduce re-experiencing, avoidance/numbing, and hyperarousal symptoms.
Critical EPPP Point: Single-session psychological debriefing (critical incident stress debriefing) is NOT effective and may worsen symptoms. If you see this as an answer choice for treating PTSD, it's wrong.
PTSD with Comorbid Substance Use Disorder
This combination is common and important. Traditional approaches treated the substance use first, then the PTSD. Research now shows integrated (concurrent) treatments work better:
- COPE (Concurrent treatment Of PTSD and SUD using Prolonged Exposure)
- Prolonged exposure for PTSD + treatment as usual for SUD
- Trauma-focused CBT + treatment as usual for SUD
For Children and Adolescents: Trauma-Focused CBT (TF-CBT) is the go-to treatment for ages 3-18. Originally designed for sexual abuse, it now addresses various trauma types and includes family therapy, parenting skills, and conjoint parent-child sessions. It effectively reduces PTSD, depression, anxiety, and grief symptoms.
Acute Stress Disorder
Think of this as "PTSD's shorter-term cousin." The trauma exposure requirement is identical, but the timeline differs:
- Symptoms last 3 days to 1 month (if they last longer, consider PTSD)
- Need at least 9 symptoms from any of five categories: intrusion, negative mood, dissociative symptoms, avoidance, arousal
- Must cause significant distress or impairment
Adjustment Disorders
Adjustment disorders are emotional or behavioral symptoms in response to an identifiable stressor of any severity (a breakup, job loss, illness, a move). The stressor does not have to be life-threatening, which is the big difference from PTSD and acute stress disorder.
Diagnostic requirements:
- Symptoms start within 3 months of the stressor
- Distress is out of proportion to the stressor (considering culture and context), and/or there is significant impairment
- Criteria for another mental disorder are not met, and it isn't just a flare-up of an existing disorder
- Not normal bereavement and not better explained by prolonged grief disorder
- Symptoms end within 6 months after the stressor (or its consequences) ends
Subtypes: with depressed mood, with anxiety, with mixed anxiety and depressed mood, with disturbance of conduct, with mixed disturbance of emotions and conduct, and unspecified.
Duration specifiers: acute (less than 6 months) or persistent (chronic) (6 months or more). Persistent applies only when the stressor itself is chronic or has lasting consequences, like a disabling illness or the fallout of a divorce.
A college freshman who has crying spells and can't focus on classes for two months after moving away from home, with no other disorder, fits adjustment disorder with depressed mood.
Timing vs. trauma disorders: Adjustment disorder can be diagnosed right away and last up to 6 months after the stressor ends. Acute stress disorder fits only between 3 days and 1 month after a trauma, and PTSD only after 1 month. After a traumatic event, someone whose symptoms fall short of the full PTSD or acute stress disorder threshold can receive an adjustment disorder.
Key facts: Adjustment disorders are common, accounting for about 5%-20% of outpatient mental health principal diagnoses in the U.S. They raise the risk of suicide attempts and suicide.
Prolonged Grief Disorder
This is a newer addition to the DSM: prolonged grief disorder was added in DSM-5-TR (2022). Requirements include:
- Death of someone close occurred at least 12 months ago (adults) or 6 months ago (children/adolescents)
- Intense yearning for the deceased and/or preoccupation with thoughts about them
- At least 3 of 8 symptoms nearly every day for the past month: disbelief about the death, avoidance of reminders, emotional numbness, intense loneliness, etc.
The key distinction: Normal grief is painful but gradually improves. Prolonged grief disorder involves persistent, intense symptoms that significantly impair functioning well beyond typical bereavement timelines.
Differential diagnosis:
- vs. major depression: in prolonged grief, the distress centers on loss of and separation from the person who died, not a general low mood. Since DSM-5, bereavement does not rule out MDD; you can diagnose MDD after a death if criteria are met
- vs. PTSD: PTSD intrusions and avoidance center on the traumatic event (such as the fatal accident). Prolonged grief intrusions center on the relationship, the avoidance is of reminders that the person is gone, and there is yearning, which PTSD lacks. Both can be diagnosed after a violent death
- Seeing or hearing the deceased briefly is common in normal grief across cultures and is not by itself psychosis
Prevalence: DSM-5-TR says the prevalence of prolonged grief disorder, as DSM defines it, is unknown. A meta-analysis using a different, 6-month definition found about 9.8%.
Dissociative Disorders: When the Mind Disconnects
The DSM-5-TR describes these as disruptions in the normal integration of consciousness, memory, identity, emotion, and behavior. It's like your mental operating system experiencing a serious glitch where different programs can't communicate with each other properly.
Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID)
DID (formerly multiple personality disorder) has two core parts:
- Two or more distinct personality states (or, in some cultures, an experience of possession), with a marked break in sense of self and sense of agency. Others may observe it, or the person may report it
- Recurrent memory gaps for everyday events, important personal information, or traumatic events that go beyond ordinary forgetting
Plus: distress or impairment; not part of a broadly accepted cultural or religious practice; not due to a substance (like alcohol blackouts) or a medical condition (like complex partial seizures). In children, it is not better explained by imaginary playmates or fantasy play.
A woman finds clothes in her closet she doesn't remember buying, and coworkers mention a meeting she has no memory of, where she seemed like "a different person."
Key facts:
- Prevalence: 1.5% (12-month) in a small U.S. community study
- Trauma link: about 90% report multiple types of childhood abuse and neglect, often starting before ages 5-6
- Suicidal behavior is frequent: over 70% of outpatients with DID have attempted suicide, and nonsuicidal self-injury is common
The controversy: Diagnoses rose sharply in the 1980s, after popular books and films like Sybil. The sociocognitive model argues DID is largely shaped by therapists looking for it (iatrogenic) and by cultural role enactment. The posttraumatic (trauma) model sees DID as a result of severe childhood trauma and points to corroborated trauma histories and brain-imaging differences between people with DID and people asked to fake it.
DID vs. schizophrenia: DID is a split in identity; schizophrenia is a split from reality. People with DID may hear personality states talking, which can look like hallucinations. But in schizophrenia these experiences usually come with delusional explanations (an outside force is inserting thoughts), while people with DID typically experience them as ego-alien and frightening.
Dissociative Amnesia
This involves an inability to recall important personal information that goes way beyond normal forgetting and causes significant distress or impairment.
Types of Amnesia (know these for the EPPP):
| Type | Description | Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Localized | Can't recall anything during a specific time period | Most common |
| Selective | Can't recall some events during a specific time period | Also common (DSM-5-TR pairs it with localized) |
| Generalized | Complete loss of memory for entire life | Rare |
| Systematized | Loss of memory for a specific category of information | Rare |
| Continuous | Can't remember new events as they occur | Rare |
Dissociative Fugue: This is a specifier for dissociative amnesia that involves purposeful travel or aimless wandering combined with memory loss. Imagine someone who suddenly finds themselves in a different city with no memory of how they got there or why they left. That's dissociative fugue.
Dissociative amnesia typically relates to victimization or trauma exposure. Its 12-month prevalence was 1.8% in a small U.S. community study.
Depersonalization/Derealization Disorder
This disorder involves persistent or recurrent episodes of:
- Depersonalization: Feeling unreal, detached, or like an outside observer of your own thoughts and actions
- Derealization: Feeling that your surroundings are unreal or distant
Critical requirement: Reality testing remains intact. The person knows these experiences aren't real. They just feel that way. Symptoms must cause significant distress or impairment.
Some people describe depersonalization as feeling like they're watching themselves in a movie, or like they're operating their body remotely. Derealization is often described as feeling like the world is behind a fog or glass wall.
Somatic Symptom and Related Disorders: When Physical Symptoms Don't Match Medical Findings
These disorders involve physical symptoms and/or health concerns that cause significant distress or impairment. The symptoms may or may not have a medical explanation. DSM-5 dropped the old "medically unexplained" requirement: somatic symptom disorder rests on an excessive response to symptoms, and functional neurological symptom disorder rests on positive signs that the symptom is incompatible with known disease.
Somatic Symptom Disorder
This diagnosis requires:
- One or more somatic symptoms that are distressing or disrupt daily life
- Excessive thoughts, emotions, or behaviors about the symptoms or health concerns, shown by at least one of:
- Disproportionate thoughts about symptom seriousness
- Persistently high anxiety about health/symptoms
- Excessive time and energy devoted to health concerns
- The state of being symptomatic is persistent, typically more than 6 months (any one symptom may come and go)
Specifiers indicate severity (mild, moderate, severe), whether pain predominates, and if the disorder is persistent (severe, marked impairment, lasting over 6 months). Severity tracks the Criterion B count: mild = 1, moderate = 2 or more, severe = 2 or more plus multiple complaints or one very severe symptom.
Prevalence: about 4%-6% of the general adult population (Europe and North America).
Important: You don't need to prove the symptoms are "psychological in origin." The diagnosis focuses on the person's response to their symptoms, not whether the symptoms have a medical explanation.
Illness Anxiety Disorder
This is what used to be called hypochondriasis. Key features:
- Preoccupation with having a serious illness
- No or mild somatic symptoms present
- Excessive health anxiety
- Either excessive health-related behaviors (frequent doctor visits, checking) or maladaptive avoidance (avoiding medical care)
- Symptoms present at least 6 months
The distinction from Somatic Symptom Disorder: In Illness Anxiety Disorder, somatic symptoms are absent or mild. The focus is on the fear of having an illness, not on distressing physical symptoms.
Prevalence: health anxiety or disease conviction runs about 1.3%-10% in community surveys, and it is similar in men and women.
Functional Neurological Symptom Disorder (Conversion Disorder)
This is one of the most fascinating diagnoses for many clinicians. The person has one or more symptoms involving disturbed voluntary motor or sensory functioning (paralysis, blindness, seizures, etc.), but:
- Symptoms are incompatible with any known neurological or medical condition
- Symptoms cause significant distress or impairment
It is not a diagnosis of exclusion. Normal test results or a "bizarre" symptom are not enough. The clinician needs positive signs of incompatibility, like Hoover's sign (weak hip extension that returns to normal strength when the person lifts the other leg against resistance) or a tremor that changes when the person is distracted. It can be diagnosed in people who also have a neurological disease, such as epilepsy.
Specifiers (DSM-5-TR):
- Acute episode (less than 6 months) vs. persistent (6 months or more)
- With psychological stressor vs. without psychological stressor. A stressor is no longer required for the diagnosis
Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)
This is a specific presentation worth knowing. PNES look like epileptic seizures behaviorally, but:
- They're NOT accompanied by abnormal brain electrical activity
- Video EEG is the gold standard for identification. It records behavior and brain activity simultaneously
- When EEG patterns don't correspond to seizure-like behaviors, PNES is likely
Think of PNES like a fire alarm going off without any actual fire, the alarm system (behavior) activates, but the trigger (abnormal brain electrical activity) isn't present.
Factitious Disorder: The Intent to Deceive
This disorder comes in two forms:
Factitious Disorder Imposed on Self:
- Person falsifies or induces physical/psychological symptoms
- Presents themselves as ill or impaired
- Engages in deception even without obvious external rewards
Factitious Disorder Imposed on Another:
- Same as above, but symptoms are induced in another person (often a child by their parent)
- The perpetrator, not the victim, receives this diagnosis. The victim may receive an abuse code (for example, child physical abuse). If the perpetrator also falsifies their own illness, both forms can be diagnosed
Malingering: Not a Mental Disorder
This is crucial for the EPPP: Malingering is NOT a mental disorder. It's listed under "Other Conditions That May Be a Focus of Clinical Attention."
Key Distinction:
| Feature | Factitious Disorder | Malingering |
|---|---|---|
| Motivation | Internal psychological need; no obvious external reward | Clear external reward (money, drugs, avoiding work/legal consequences) |
| Awareness | May not be fully aware of motivations | Fully aware; intentional deception |
| DSM Status | Mental disorder | NOT a mental disorder |
When to Suspect Malingering:
- Medical evaluation sought for legal reasons
- Marked discrepancy between reported symptoms and objective findings
- Uncooperative with evaluation or treatment
- Presence of Antisocial Personality Disorder
Detecting Feigned Symptoms
The forced-choice method is valuable for detecting malingering. It presents test items requiring selection from alternatives. It's based on a simple principle: even random guessing should produce about 50% correct answers with true/false items. If someone scores significantly below chance (well under 50%), they must be deliberately choosing wrong answers. "Significantly" is a statistical judgment (a binomial test), not just any score under 50%. On a 50-item two-choice test, 23 correct is still consistent with guessing.
Distinguishing Genuine from Feigned Memory Loss:
| Feature | Genuine Memory Loss | Feigned Memory Loss |
|---|---|---|
| Onset/Termination | Gradual, hazy | Often sudden, clear-cut |
| Memory Fragments | Often remembers some fragments | Claims complete loss for the period |
| Belief about Recovery | Believes hints/clues might help | Less likely to engage with memory aids |
Assessment Tools:
Test of Memory Malingering (TOMM): Uses forced-choice format with images (50 items per trial; Trial 1, Trial 2, and an optional Retention trial). Invalid performance is flagged by a score below a cutoff on Trial 2 or Retention, traditionally below 45 of 50. A 2020 meta-analysis supports a stricter cutoff of below 49 for people without significant cognitive impairment, but specificity drops in dementia. Scores significantly below chance are a separate, rarer sign and strong evidence of deliberately wrong answers. A failed validity test shows the results can't be trusted; calling it malingering also requires evidence of an external incentive.
Common Misconceptions Students Have
Misconception 1: "PTSD only happens to combat veterans." Reality: PTSD can develop after any trauma involving actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violence. Car accidents, assaults, natural disasters, medical emergencies, etc.
Misconception 2: "Dissociative amnesia is just 'forgetting' due to not paying attention." Reality: This is an inability to recall important personal information that far exceeds ordinary forgetting and is typically trauma-related.
Misconception 3: "People with Somatic Symptom Disorder are faking their symptoms." Reality: Their physical symptoms are real and distressing. The issue is excessive thoughts, feelings, and behaviors about these symptoms.
Misconception 4: "Critical incident stress debriefing helps prevent PTSD." Reality: Research shows it's ineffective and may actually worsen symptoms. This is a common wrong answer on the EPPP.
Misconception 5: "Factitious disorder and malingering are the same thing." Reality: Factitious disorder is a mental disorder involving deception without obvious external rewards. Malingering is intentional symptom production for external gain and is NOT a mental disorder.
Practice Tips for Remembering
For Trauma Disorders, remember the timeline:
- Acute Stress Disorder: 3 days to 1 month
- PTSD: More than 1 month
- Prolonged Grief: 12 months (adults) or 6 months (children/adolescents) after death
For RAD vs. DSED: Think withdrawal vs. indiscriminate friendliness
- RAD: child pulls away
- DSED: child goes toward everyone
For PTSD treatment hierarchy:
- First-line: CPT, PE, trauma-focused CBT (remember "CPT-PE-CBT")
- Second-line: CT, EMDR, NET
- NO first-line medications
- Avoid critical incident stress debriefing
For Dissociative Amnesia types, use the acronym LSSGC:
- Localized (most common)
- Selective
- Systematized
- Generalized
- Continuous
For Somatic vs. Illness Anxiety:
- Somatic Symptom Disorder = distressing physical symptoms PRESENT
- Illness Anxiety Disorder = symptoms absent or MILD, fear of disease dominates
For Factitious vs. Malingering:
- Factitious = no obvious external reward (internal psychological need)
- Malingering = clear external reward (money, drugs, avoiding consequences)
- Only factitious is a mental disorder
For detecting malingering: Remember forced-choice scoring below chance = deliberate wrong answers
Key Takeaways
- All Trauma/Stressor-Related Disorders require trauma/stress exposure as a diagnostic criterion
- PTSD involves four symptom categories: intrusion, avoidance, negative mood/cognition, and altered arousal/reactivity
- First-line PTSD treatments are CPT, PE, and trauma-focused CBT; no medications are first-line
- Critical incident stress debriefing is ineffective and potentially harmful
- Integrated treatments work better than sequential approaches for PTSD with comorbid substance use
- Dissociative disorders involve disruption in consciousness, memory, identity, or perception
- Localized amnesia (inability to recall events during a specific period) is the most common type
- Depersonalization/Derealization Disorder requires intact reality testing
- Somatic Symptom Disorder focuses on excessive responses to symptoms, not whether symptoms are "real"
- Conversion Disorder symptoms are incompatible with known medical/neurological conditions
- Video EEG distinguishes PNES from true epileptic seizures
- Factitious Disorder (a mental disorder) involves deception without obvious external rewards
- Malingering (NOT a mental disorder) involves intentional symptom production for external gain
- Forced-choice testing showing significantly below-chance performance suggests deliberate wrong answers; on the TOMM, invalid effort is usually flagged by a Trial 2 or Retention cutoff (traditionally below 45 of 50)
- Adjustment disorders start within 3 months of a stressor of any severity and end within 6 months after the stressor ends
- DID requires two or more personality states (or possession) plus recurrent amnesia; prolonged grief disorder is new in DSM-5-TR (2022)
- In factitious disorder imposed on another, the perpetrator gets the diagnosis, not the victim
- Genuine memory loss has gradual onset/termination; feigned memory loss often has sudden onset/termination
Understanding these disorders requires appreciating how trauma, stress, and psychological distress can manifest in diverse ways. From intrusive memories to disconnection from reality to unexplained physical symptoms. For the EPPP, focus on distinguishing similar disorders, knowing treatment hierarchies, and understanding the role of trauma exposure in diagnosis.
